Skip to content

Fire and Ice

Important Questions/PYQs

Gist:

Fire and ice is a compact poem written by Robert Frost. It expresses the profound idea that the world would end in either of two ways- by fire or by ice. People are divided in this issue. Some believe that fire will become the cause of the end and others think that ice will end the world. Both the components are compared with self-destructing human emotions: hatred and desire. He says that from what he is aware about “fiery desires”, he would favor the ones who say that it would be fire. But later he says that Ice or hatred, created by cold reasoning is also equally capable of destroying the world. Therefore, if Earth was to end twice, ice would be just as good as fire. If fire would lead to rapid destruction, ice would lead to silent damage.

Extract Based Questions:

1. Some say the world will end in fire some say in ice.
From what I‘ve tasted of desire I hold with those who favour fire.

A) Who wrote these lines?

View Answer

Ans. Robert Frost


B) What is the poet‘s opinion about the world?

View Answer

Ans. According to the poet, the world will end in fire


C) What is the contradictory opinion of public?

View Answer

Ans. The contradictory opinion of public is the debate whether the world will end in fire or ice.


D) How are ice and fire similar to each other though they have contradictory traits?

View Answer

Ans. Both ice and fire are similar in the in the sense that both of them would destroy everything in the world


2. But if it had to perish twice I think I know enough of hate
To say that for destruction ice Is also great
And would suffice.

A) What does ‘it’ refers to in the first line?

View Answer

Ans. ‘It’ refers to the world.


B) What do you mean by ‘perish’?

View Answer

Ans. Perish means to die or to be destroyed.


C) What does ice stand for?

View Answer

Ans. Ice stands for coldness or hatred.


D) What would be two causes of destruction?

View Answer

Ans. Ice or fire would be the cause of destruction.


Short Answer Questions:

1. Which age old question does the poem revolves around?

View Answer

Ans. The poem revolves around the age old question of whether the world will end in fire or in ice. People are divided in this issue. Some believe that fire will become the cause of the end and others think that ice will end the world. Here, fire symbolizes human desire and ice symbolizes hatred.


2. Why does the poet hold with those who favour fire?

View Answer

Ans. The poet takes side with those who believe that the world will be destroyed by fire. Frost connects fire with desire. According to the poet, desire is powerful and would be a quick end. Moreover, the fact that he has had personal experience with desire leads him to first conclude that the world will end in fire.


3. What does ‘ice‘ stand for? How is it sufficient to bring destruction?

View Answer

Ans. Ice symbolizes hatred. Hate is just as powerful as desire. While desire consumes quickly, hate can occur and linger in people‘s minds and hearts for years and sometimes even lifetimes. Hate can, thus, be very destructive and sufficient to bring destruction.


Long Answer Questions:

1. What do the metaphors of Ice and Fire convey to the reader? Elaborate. What is the message given by the poet?

View Answer

Ans. Frost presents the two of the darkest traits of humanity; the capacity to hate and the capacity to be consumed by lust or desire. Of the two, he attributes the greater of the two evils, is desire. In giving desire the foremost position with regard to the destruction of the world, Frost is providing a powerful statement on the subject of greed and jealousy, saying that above all trait of humanity that is most likely to lead to its demise. Desire represents the greatest problem that attributes to the cause of the war. Frost then attributes hatred with the same capacity to do harm. However, he lessens the relative importance of hatred but still presents it as having the ability to lead to the destruction of the world if it were to happen for a second time.


Previous Year Questions:

1. “Fire and Ice” was first published in 1920. Briefly explain how World War I might have influenced the theme of the poem.

View Answers

Ans. The poem is written shortly after the end of the first world war and is greatly influenced. The war proved it right how men’s technological, economic and intellectual progress led to self-destruction. The speaker is worried about the survival of the world.


2. Create a tag line / slogan / catchphrase for the poem.

View Answers

Ans. “Overdevelopment sometimes lead to self-destruction”
“If you ignore nature, nature will ignore you”
“Self-satisfaction is mandatory to avoid self-destruction”
“Show empathy towards nature”


3. The tone of the speaker contrasts with the seriousness of the subject matter. Justify.

View Answers

Ans. The speaker is presenting his personal opinion about the possibilities of the end of the world which is a serious matter. But the speaker’s tone is casual and conversational. He talks with the reader as if they are his friend. He is using casual words like, ‘some say’, ‘I hold with’, ‘I think I know’ etc.


4. Fire and Ice project a pessimistic outlook. Comment.

View Answers

Ans. The poet links human desire to be the reason for the possible extinction of the world. The poem tries to imply that humanity should not try to innovate and develop new weapons. It projects a pessimistic outlook by suggesting that following dreams and passion by humankind may lead to catastrophic destruction on the earth.


5. Evaluate the line- Some say the world will end in fire/Some say in ice- in the context of volcanic eruptions, forest fires, meteor collisions, melting ice caps etc.

View Answers

Ans. There have been incidents of natural disasters that created havoc on earth. Every year forest fires, volcanic eruptions account for a huge loss of flora and fauna and even humans. Fires due to meteor collisions cause measurable effects on life. Loss of person and property in Uttarakhand, India (Kedarnath temple) could be attributed to the melting ice caps.


6. Imagine that Nelson Mandela read ‘Fire and Ice’. As Mandela, write a diary entry associating the impact of the troubled history of South Africa with the idea expressed in the poem.

You may begin like this:
10 May 1994, Tuesday 10 p.m.
Today, when I am the President of South Africa, I can’t help recalling Robert
Frost’s ‘Fire and Ice’…………………(continue)………………….

View Answers

Ans.

10 May 1994,

Tuesday 10 p.m.
Today, when I am the President of South Africa, I can’t help recalling Robert
Frost’s Fire and Ice. As Frost said if the world had to perish twice ice would suffice. I agree that hatred and indifference are sharper than any weapon to end the world. Half of the population of South Africa was forced to bear the tortures of apartheid.
Today, we are free but humanity needs real independence from hatred and partiality. People of any colour and caste is no less than the other. The world seems beautiful only when you have beautiful eyes. Everyone has to be empathetic towards the less privileged people and a life-supporting natural environment. All should try to make a strong foundation based on equality and empathy to sustain life on earth.


7. Most of your classmates, like Frost, feel that man’s greed and rage or hate would lead the world to its destruction.

You feel that the ‘fire and ice’ in Mankind can be addressed to create a harmonious world. Write a speech, for your classmates, expressing your belief/s with respect to the poem.

View Answers

Ans. Speech (Fire and Ice)
Good morning teachers and my friends! I do not believe in the pessimistic view of Sir Robert Frost that our desires can take the world near to destruction. I feel that this fire and ice can be tamed to cultivate a harmonious relationship among people.
“Necessity is the mother of invention”. A man without desire is no more than an animal. Human has added comfort to his life by keeping passions and desires alive. I agree that unchecked aspirations sometimes turn harmful. However, by making strict rules and staying vigilant, this fire can be kept under control. Fire adds taste to food but burns the house as well if left uncontrolled.

Today, we are more concerned about nature that got depleted due to the indifferent attitude towards the environment. Until our actions are controlled we need not worry about the end of the world.